Firms with lower disclosure on their anticorruption efforts may make more sales in corrupt countries than their high-disclosure peers, but they are likely to make less money from them, according to a new working paper from Harvard Business School.
The study examines 480 of the world’s largest companies, using ratings by Transparency International of firms’ public disclosures of strategy, policies, and management systems for combatting corruption. Professors Paul Healy and George Serafeim find that firm disclosures are related to enforcement and monitoring costs, such as home country enforcement, US listing, big four auditors, and prior enforcement actions. Disclosures also reflect industry and country corruption risks. Meanwhile the financial implications of fighting disclosure are more nuanced. Key concepts include:
- While firm-level research on corruption is still at the formative stage, findings suggest that disclosure is more than cheap talk.
- Firms with high disclosure on their anticorruption efforts are committed to fighting corruption. The policies and enforcement actions reflected in their disclosures help to protect their public reputation and profitability, but at the cost of slower sales growth in high corruption risk markets.
- Firms with abnormally low disclosure have roughly 15 percent higher sales growth in corrupt country markets than their high disclosure peers. But this higher growth is accompanied by lower profit margins and return on equity.
- Firms with abnormally high anticorruption ratings have a lower frequency of subsequent allegations of corruption in the media, suggesting that disclosures reflect their commitment to fighting corruption.
- Future research could examine (among other issues) what factors, other than monitoring/enforcement costs and risk exposures, explain the differences in firms’ level of disclosure and commitment to fight corruption.
Fore details, see Causes and Consequences of Firm Disclosures of Anticorruption Efforts
Technorati Tags: corporate-governance, corruption, disclosure