Selective Insurance Group’s third quarter was marked by a significant market disappointment, with management attributing underperformance to elevated loss trends in commercial auto, particularly in New Jersey. CEO John Marchioni called out “unfavorable prior year casualty reserve development” as a primary factor, noting $35 million in commercial auto charges and ongoing challenges in specific jurisdictions. Management’s tone was notably cautious, acknowledging that rate increases alone will not restore profitability in affected lines. Additional reserve reviews by external third parties confirmed Selective’s processes are consistent with industry best practices, but the company’s results were pressured by ongoing severity trends.

Is now the time to buy SIGI? Find out in our full research report (it’s free for active Edge members).

While we enjoy listening to the management's commentary, our favorite part of earnings calls are the analyst questions. Those are unscripted and can often highlight topics that management teams would rather avoid or topics where the answer is complicated. Here is what has caught our attention.

Our Top 5 Analyst Questions From Selective Insurance Group’s Q3 Earnings Call

• Michael Phillips (Oppenheimer) pressed CEO John Marchioni about the shift in commercial auto reserve trends and why prior confidence in these lines did not materialize, especially in New Jersey. Marchioni explained the acceleration in severity trends was isolated but significant, emphasizing ongoing monitoring and corrective actions.
• Michael Zaremski (BMO Capital Markets) questioned the rationale for continuing share buybacks amid reserve pressure and ongoing claim reviews. Marchioni defended the buybacks, citing strong capital generation and external validation of reserves.
• Paul Newsome (Piper Sandler) asked about the potential impact of conservative underwriting on premium growth, particularly if shrinking auto business would affect package policies. Marchioni acknowledged growth would be slower but reiterated margin discipline as the priority.
• Jian Huang (Morgan Stanley) inquired about the stability of claim frequencies and the company’s approach to further strengthening the balance sheet. Marchioni stated fundamentals and targeted margins would guide future actions, not simply growing the balance sheet for its own sake.
• Unknown Analyst (KBW) probed the effectiveness of geographic expansion and agent receptivity in new states. Marchioni noted initial results were favorable and consistent with the existing business mix, emphasizing diversification’s role in lowering concentration risk.

Catalysts in Upcoming Quarters

The StockStory team will be watching (1) the pace and effectiveness of commercial auto underwriting actions, particularly in high-severity states like New Jersey; (2) the impact of geographic and segment diversification on reducing volatility and concentration risk; and (3) continued progress in deploying predictive analytics and telematics to improve loss ratios. Execution on these fronts, alongside disciplined capital management, will be key markers of Selective Insurance’s ability to deliver on its long-term margin targets.

Selective Insurance Group currently trades at $75.61, down from $81.40 just before the earnings. In the wake of this quarter, is it a buy or sell? See for yourself in our full research report (it’s free for active Edge members).

The Best Stocks for High-Quality Investors

When Trump unveiled his aggressive tariff plan in April 2025, markets tanked as investors feared a full-blown trade war. But those who panicked and sold missed the subsequent rebound that’s already erased most losses.

Don’t let fear keep you from great opportunities and take a look at Top 5 Growth Stocks for this month. This is a curated list of our High Quality stocks that have generated a market-beating return of 183% over the last five years (as of March 31st 2025).

Stocks that made our list in 2020 include now familiar names such as Nvidia (+1,545% between March 2020 and March 2025) as well as under-the-radar businesses like the once-small-cap company Exlservice (+354% five-year return). Find your next big winner with StockStory today.

StockStory is growing and hiring equity analyst and marketing roles. Are you a 0 to 1 builder passionate about the markets and AI? See the open roles here.