Property and casualty insurer Selective Insurance Group (NASDAQ: SIGI) met Wall Street’s revenue expectations in Q2 CY2025, with sales up 10.9% year on year to $1.33 billion. Its non-GAAP profit of $1.31 per share was 13.6% below analysts’ consensus estimates.

Is now the time to buy SIGI? Find out in our full research report (it’s free).

StockStory’s Take

Selective Insurance Group’s second quarter results were met with a negative market reaction, as the company’s non-GAAP earnings per share fell short of Wall Street’s expectations. Management pointed to continued strength in investment income and solid performance in its Excess and Surplus and Personal Lines segments. However, unfavorable reserve development in casualty lines, specifically general liability and commercial auto, drove up the combined ratio. CEO John Marchioni acknowledged, “We responded to elevated recent accident year paid emergence this quarter,” emphasizing that these pressures were broad-based across geographies and industries, not isolated to specific accounts.

Looking ahead, Selective Insurance Group’s forward outlook is shaped by a cautious approach to underwriting and pricing, especially in the face of persistent social inflation—an industry term describing rising claims costs driven by societal and legal trends. Management expects to maintain rate increases above loss trends, but also anticipates slower premium growth as underwriting guidelines are tightened and certain underperforming segments are trimmed. Marchioni noted, “We believe emphasizing improving underwriting margins and tempering the top line in the current environment is prudent,” underscoring the company’s focus on long-term profitability over rapid expansion.

Key Insights from Management’s Remarks

Management attributed the quarter’s results to proactive reserve strengthening in casualty lines and a deliberate shift toward underwriting discipline and portfolio diversification.

• Casualty reserve strengthening: Selective took significant reserve additions for prior accident years in general liability and commercial auto, citing higher-than-expected claim severity and ongoing social inflation. These adjustments were made in response to recent paid claims data, not older accident years.
• Social inflation impact: CEO John Marchioni explained that industry-wide legal and societal trends are driving up claims costs, particularly in casualty lines involving bodily injury. This “social inflation” is impacting both the frequency and severity of claims and is not unique to Selective’s portfolio.
• Underwriting and pricing actions: The company continued to raise renewal prices, especially in general liability and commercial auto, with renewal pure price increases outpacing loss trends. However, these pricing actions have put downward pressure on new business conversion rates and led to slightly lower retention in the commercial lines segment.
• Portfolio diversification efforts: Management outlined ongoing strategies to diversify Selective’s business mix, including expanding its Excess & Surplus (E&S) business and focusing personal lines growth on the mass affluent segment. The company is also gradually giving retail agents access to its E&S products, aiming for balanced growth over time.
• Claims management enhancements: Selective has implemented more specialized claims handling, increased use of litigation analytics, and developed new tools to quickly identify cases likely to involve legal representation. These steps are designed to better manage claim costs and outcomes in a challenging environment.

Drivers of Future Performance

Selective Insurance Group’s guidance for the remainder of the year centers on disciplined risk management, ongoing pricing adjustments, and the potential for continued volatility from social inflation.

• Continued pricing discipline: Management intends to maintain rate increases above anticipated loss trends, particularly in casualty lines. This approach, while supportive of long-term margins, is expected to limit premium growth as retention declines and underwriting standards tighten.
• Operational and claims improvements: The company is investing in enhanced claims analytics, fraud detection, and specialized claims handling to identify problem areas earlier and mitigate adverse development. These operational changes are expected to gradually improve profitability, though recent accident years remain a source of uncertainty.
• Portfolio rebalancing: Selective plans to further diversify its book by expanding E&S offerings and focusing on personal lines growth in targeted, more profitable segments. The company also expects some moderation in property rate increases, reflecting improving profitability in that segment, but continues to monitor catastrophe exposure and external cost pressures.

Catalysts in Upcoming Quarters

In the coming quarters, the StockStory team will be watching (1) the effectiveness of Selective’s rate increases and underwriting discipline in stabilizing margins, (2) signs that social inflation and claim severity trends are moderating, and (3) progress in expanding the E&S segment and capturing targeted personal lines growth. The trajectory of catastrophe losses and the impact of operational enhancements in claims management will also be important markers for assessing execution.

Selective Insurance Group currently trades at $74.62, down from $90.46 just before the earnings. Is the company at an inflection point that warrants a buy or sell? See for yourself in our full research report (it’s free).

Now Could Be The Perfect Time To Invest In These Stocks

Donald Trump’s April 2024 "Liberation Day" tariffs sent markets into a tailspin, but stocks have since rebounded strongly, proving that knee-jerk reactions often create the best buying opportunities.

The smart money is already positioning for the next leg up. Don’t miss out on the recovery - check out our Top 5 Growth Stocks for this month. This is a curated list of our High Quality stocks that have generated a market-beating return of 183% over the last five years (as of March 31st 2025).

Stocks that made our list in 2020 include now familiar names such as Nvidia (+1,545% between March 2020 and March 2025) as well as under-the-radar businesses like the once-micro-cap company Tecnoglass (+1,754% five-year return). Find your next big winner with StockStory today.

StockStory is growing and hiring equity analyst and marketing roles. Are you a 0 to 1 builder passionate about the markets and AI? See the open roles here.